Skip to content

Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

  • Health

Many individuals aim for a balanced diet, conscientiously avoiding obvious sugar culprits like sodas, candies, and pastries. However, what often goes unnoticed is the stealthy sugar lurking in everyday condiments. While a dollop here and a splash there might seem harmless, these seemingly savory additions can significantly contribute to one’s daily sugar intake. By bringing these condiments into the spotlight, this article seeks to provide a clearer picture of where some of those hidden sugars lie, empowering readers to make more informed dietary choices.

Barbecue Sauce

Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

Barbecue sauce, a favorite for grilling and marinades, is notorious for its sweet and tangy flavor. This delightful taste often comes from a blend of ingredients, including molasses, brown sugar, and sometimes even high-fructose corn syrup. Given its flavor profile, it shouldn’t be surprising that a substantial portion of its caloric content comes from sugars.

A mere two-tablespoon serving of some commercial BBQ sauces can pack in upwards of 10 grams of sugar. This is equivalent to nearly two and a half teaspoons of granulated sugar, a fact that can certainly catch anyone off guard if they aren’t scrutinizing labels.


Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

Ketchup reigns supreme as one of the most beloved condiments worldwide. Its unique flavor enhances everything from fries to burgers. However, that signature taste often comes with a hidden cost: sugar. Many commercial ketchup brands utilize high-fructose corn syrup or other sugars to achieve the perfect balance of sweet and tangy.

Just a single tablespoon of ketchup can contain about 4 grams of sugar. That might not sound like much, but considering how liberally ketchup is often used, it’s easy to see how quickly those grams can accumulate. As with many condiments, the key is moderation and awareness of what’s inside.

Salad Dressings

Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

Salad dressings are meant to elevate the flavors of fresh vegetables and greens, but many store-bought varieties have a hidden component: sugar. Especially in dressings that tout a fruity or creamy profile, sugars are often added to create a tantalizing balance between tanginess and sweetness. For many, the idea that a dressing could be sugar-laden is counterintuitive, especially when one is trying to opt for a healthier meal choice with salads.

However, it’s crucial to remain vigilant. Some commercial dressings can contain as much as 5 to 7 grams of sugar in a single serving, which might be just two tablespoons. Reading ingredient lists and nutritional labels becomes essential for those wanting to keep their sugar intake in check. Alternatives like making dressings at home can be both healthier and more flavorful.

Teriyaki Sauce

Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

Originating from Japan, teriyaki sauce has found its place in kitchens around the globe. With its harmonious blend of sweet and savory, it’s a preferred choice for marinades and glazes. However, this distinct taste is often achieved by incorporating a high volume of sugars, particularly when it comes to mass-produced versions available in supermarkets.

On average, a tablespoon of commercial teriyaki sauce can contain up to 5 grams of sugar, which is considerable given the small serving size. For those who love the rich flavor of teriyaki but want to reduce sugar consumption, seeking out lower-sugar recipes or brands is a wise step. Making a homemade version allows for control over ingredients and can result in a sauce that’s just as delicious without the excess sweeteners.

Fruit Jams and Preserves

Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

Fruit jams and preserves bring the essence of fresh fruits into a spreadable form, enhancing breakfasts and snacks. Naturally, fruits come with their sugars, but many commercial jams add a significant amount of sweeteners to extend shelf life and enhance flavor. This can sometimes overshadow the natural sweetness and flavor of the fruit itself.

It’s not uncommon for a tablespoon of jam to contain more than 10 grams of sugar. To savor the true essence of fruits without the added sugars, it’s worth considering brands that have a “no added sugar” label or venturing into the world of homemade jams. Using natural sweeteners like honey or relying on the fruit’s inherent sweetness can make for a healthier, yet equally delectable, spread.

Yogurt-Based Dips

Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

Yogurt-based dips, with their creamy texture and rich flavor profile, are often seen as a healthier alternative to other creamy dips. It’s true that yogurt offers beneficial probiotics and can be a source of protein. However, when it comes to certain yogurt dips, especially those with fruit flavors or those labeled as “low-fat,” added sugars can become a primary ingredient to enhance taste and mask the tanginess of the yogurt.

In some cases, a single serving of these dips can have sugar levels that rival those of dessert yogurts or even some ice creams. For those looking to enjoy the creaminess of yogurt-based dips without the additional sugars, it’s advisable to start with plain yogurt and add in herbs, spices, or fresh fruit. This way, the dip remains flavorful, and sugar levels stay under control.

Honey Mustard

Condiments That Are Surprisingly High Sugar

Honey mustard combines the natural sweetness of honey with the tangy kick of mustard, resulting in a condiment that pairs well with a variety of dishes. Given that honey is a main ingredient, some sweetness is to be expected. However, some commercial brands amplify this sweetness by adding extra sugars or syrups, pushing the sugar content even higher.

Consumers might be surprised to find that a two-tablespoon serving of some honey mustards can contain up to 10 grams of sugar or more. While honey mustard is undeniably delicious, it’s worth noting the sugar content and considering either moderation in its use or switching to brands with minimal added sugars. Alternatively, making honey mustard at home can allow for adjustments in sweetness according to preference.

The Bottom Line

Hidden sugars in condiments can easily fly under the radar, turning seemingly healthy meals into sugar-laden dishes. By shining a light on these unsuspecting culprits, individuals can become more informed about what they’re adding to their meals. Vigilance in reading labels, opting for no-sugar-added variants, and even crafting homemade versions of beloved condiments can make a significant difference in overall sugar consumption. Awareness is the first step to healthier choices, ensuring that these flavorful additions enhance meals without compromising health.